GTA:What You Should Expect from CS Unit Academic Staff

From Computer Science Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

← Back to GTA Main Page

TL;DR

  • Introduce themselves to the GTAs before teaching starts.
  • Prepare weekly guidance for the GTAs; this could include answers to common questions, solutions to exercises, or tips for making the session run smoothly, but it will depend on the individual module.
  • Be approachable, professional, and unbiased, and offer help when requested.
  • Step in to help the GTAs if a problematic or personal welfare situation arises.
  • Turn up to scheduled sessions and stay for the entire session.
  • Prepare coursework on Canvas and release it to the GTAs in time for the GTAs to study it before the session.
  • Understand if a GTA needs to drop their module due to work or personal reasons.
  • Be knowledgeable and communicate to the GTAs their role during the sessions.


Before Teaching Starts

Introduction and Welcome

What to Expect

  • Course Unit Lead should introduce themselves to you before teaching begins
  • Initial meeting or communication (face-to-face, email, or video call) to welcome you to the teaching team
  • Introduction to other GTAs working on the same unit
  • Overview of the unit – aims, structure, assessment, your role

Why This Matters

  • Establishes a professional relationship from the outset
  • Helps you feel welcomed and valued as part of the team
  • Provides context for your work – you understand where you fit in
  • Creates an open channel for communication
  • Demonstrates that the Course Unit Lead is organised and prepared

What This Should Include

  • Course Unit Lead's name and contact details
  • Best methods for contacting them (email, office hours, etc.)
  • Overview of the unit structure and schedule
  • Your specific role and responsibilities
  • Names of other GTAs and teaching staff
  • Key dates and deadlines

If This Doesn't Happen

  • Reach out proactively – email the Course Unit Lead to introduce yourself
  • Ask for a brief meeting to discuss your role
  • If you receive no response, contact your GTA Lead (Simon Harper)
  • Don't wait until the first session to sort this out

Clear Role Definition

What to Expect

  • Clear communication about what you'll be doing in sessions
  • Specific responsibilities defined (e.g., demonstrating, answering questions, supervising practicals)
  • Boundaries of your role – what you're not expected to do
  • Time allocation – how your contracted hours should be distributed
  • Expected preparation – what you need to do before sessions

Examples of Good Role Definition

  • "You'll be demonstrating in the lab sessions on Wednesdays 2-4pm. Students will be working through practical exercises, and your role is to circulate, answer questions, and help debug code. You're not expected to mark work or handle pastoral issues."
  • "Your role includes leading the tutorial, marking the weekly problem sheets, and being available for 1 hour per week for student queries. Preparation time is estimated at 2 hours per week."

Examples of Poor Role Definition

  • "Just help out in the labs." (Too vague)
  • "Cover whatever needs doing." (No clear boundaries)
  • "We'll figure it out as we go." (Lacks planning)

Why Clear Definition Matters

  • You can prepare appropriately
  • You know what's within your remit and what to refer to staff
  • You can plan your time effectively
  • Prevents scope creep – being asked to do more than contracted
  • Reduces anxiety about what's expected

Access to Materials and Resources

What to Expect

  • Access to course materials well before sessions (ideally 1 week minimum)
  • Materials should be complete and ready – not rushed or unfinished
  • All necessary resources provided:
    • Lecture slides and notes
    • Practical exercises and solutions
    • Marking schemes (if you're marking)
    • Model answers or examples
    • Any software or datasets needed

Timing of Access

  • Before semester starts – overview materials and schedule
  • At least 1 week before sessions – detailed materials for upcoming teaching
  • Earlier for marking – schemes should be available when you start marking

What This Enables

  • Adequate preparation time – you can study materials thoroughly
  • Questions to be asked – you have time to clarify uncertainties
  • Confidence in sessions – you know what you're teaching
  • Quality teaching – well-prepared GTAs teach better
  • Managing your time – you can plan PhD work around preparation

If Materials Are Late or Incomplete

  • Request materials explicitly – "I need the materials for next week's session by [date] to prepare adequately."
  • Explain the impact – "Without the solutions, I won't be able to help students effectively."
  • Flag concerns early – don't wait until the day before
  • Document the issue – keep records of when you requested materials
  • Escalate if necessary – if this is a pattern, raise with your GTA Lead

Weekly Guidance and Support

What to Expect

Course Unit Leads should prepare weekly guidance for GTAs, which could include:

  • Answers to common questions students typically ask
  • Solutions to exercises students will be working on
  • Tips for making the session run smoothly
  • Heads-up about tricky concepts or common misconceptions
  • Updates or changes to the session plan
  • Marking guidance (if applicable that week)

Format

This guidance might be:

  • A brief document or email
  • Notes added to the course materials
  • Discussed in a weekly GTA meeting
  • Posted on Blackboard or shared drive

The format matters less than the content – you need the information to teach effectively.

Why This Matters

  • Anticipates challenges – you're prepared for difficult questions
  • Consistency across GTAs – everyone teaches to the same standard
  • Saves your time – you don't have to figure out everything independently
  • Quality assurance – students get consistent, accurate help
  • Shows the Course Unit Lead is engaged and supporting you

Individual Module Variations

The guidance will depend on the individual module:

  • Programming modules might focus on common errors and debugging strategies
  • Theory modules might highlight conceptual difficulties
  • Project-based modules might provide assessment criteria clarification

The Course Unit Lead knows their module and should tailor guidance appropriately.

If Weekly Guidance Isn't Provided

  • Ask for it – "Would it be possible to provide brief guidance each week on common issues?"
  • Suggest what would help – "Notes on typical student questions would be really useful."
  • Create your own notes – document what you discover and share with other GTAs
  • Discuss with other GTAs – peer support can partially fill this gap
  • Raise concerns if lack of guidance affects teaching quality

During the Teaching Period

Accessibility and Approachability

What to Expect

Course Unit Leads should be:

  • Approachable – you feel comfortable asking questions or raising concerns
  • Professional – treating you with respect and courtesy
  • Unbiased – no favouritism or unfair treatment
  • Available – responding to communications in reasonable timeframes
  • Helpful – offering support when requested

Approachability in Practice

  • Responds to emails within 48 hours (working days)
  • Welcomes questions – doesn't make you feel stupid for asking
  • Takes concerns seriously – listens and addresses issues
  • Open communication style – doesn't communicate only through directives
  • Visible and accessible – attends sessions, has office hours, or provides alternatives

Professional Standards

  • Respectful language and tone in all communications
  • Acknowledges your contributions and thanks you for your work
  • Provides constructive feedback rather than criticism
  • Maintains appropriate boundaries (not overly familiar, not cold and distant)
  • Models good practice – demonstrates the standards they expect

If Course Unit Lead Is Not Approachable

  • Document specific incidents – what happened, when, and how it affected you
  • Try to address directly – "I'd find it easier to ask questions if..."
  • Seek support from GTA Lead – describe the issues you're experiencing
  • Don't suffer in silence – inaccessible staff affect your ability to do your job
  • Remember your rights – you deserve professional treatment

Attendance at Sessions

What to Expect

  • Course Unit Lead should turn up to scheduled sessions
  • Should stay for the entire session (or arrange appropriate cover)
  • Should be actively engaged – not just present but participating

Why This Is Important

  • You're not solely responsible – GTAs work under supervision
  • Complex questions can be referred to the Course Unit Lead
  • Student welfare issues can be handled appropriately
  • Quality assurance – the lead sees how the teaching is going
  • Support for you – you have backup if problems arise
  • Models professionalism – showing the session matters

Course Unit Lead's Role in Sessions

  • Available for complex questions beyond GTA expertise
  • Monitors how the session is going – pacing, student engagement, issues
  • Supports GTAs – steps in if you need help
  • Handles disruptions or difficult situations
  • Provides immediate feedback – what's working, what could improve

If Course Unit Lead Is Absent

  • Occasional absences are understandable (illness, conferences, emergencies)
  • Should provide advance notice when possible
  • Should arrange appropriate cover – another member of staff or clear instructions
  • Frequent absence is problematic – this should be raised

What to Do If This Is an Issue

  • Keep a log – when they were absent, whether notice was given
  • Note the impact – "I couldn't answer student questions about X" or "A student had a welfare concern I wasn't equipped to handle"
  • Raise with your GTA Lead – this affects your ability to work safely and effectively
  • Don't try to cover for persistent absence – this is beyond your responsibility

Support During Sessions

What to Expect

When the Course Unit Lead is present in sessions, they should:

  • Be available for consultation – you can approach them with questions
  • Circulate – not just sit at the front
  • Step in to help if you're struggling with a question or situation
  • Handle problems that are beyond your role (welfare, misconduct, complex academic issues)
  • Back you up – support your authority as a GTA

Problematic Situations They Should Handle

  • Student welfare concerns – a student is distressed or discloses personal issues
  • Behavioural problems – disruptive, disrespectful, or inappropriate student behaviour
  • Academic misconduct – suspected plagiarism or cheating
  • Questions far beyond scope – theoretical questions beyond the unit content
  • Technical problems – system failures, software issues affecting whole class
  • Complaints – if a student complains about teaching or marking

Why You Shouldn't Handle These Alone

  • Not your job – these require staff authority or expertise
  • Risk to you – handling welfare or behavioural issues without training is risky
  • Risk to students – they need appropriate professional support
  • Liability – the University is responsible, not you personally
  • Your primary role – is teaching support, not pastoral care or disciplinary action

How to Get Support in the Moment

  • Approach the Course Unit Lead directly – "Could you help with this situation?"
  • Be specific – "This student seems very distressed" or "This question is beyond what I can answer"
  • Don't feel embarrassed – asking for help is professional, not weakness
  • If Course Unit Lead is not present – handle immediate safety (use SafeZone if needed), then report afterwards

Communication and Responsiveness

What to Expect

  • Timely responses to your communications (emails, messages)
  • Clear communication – not ambiguous or assuming you understand
  • Regular updates – any changes to sessions, materials, expectations
  • Two-way communication – they listen to you as well as directing you
  • Appropriate channels – using University email and systems

Reasonable Response Times

  • Routine queries: Within 48 hours (working days)
  • Urgent issues: Same day or next working day
  • Out of hours: Not expected to respond (unless genuine emergency)
  • Semester breaks: Response times may be longer, but this should be communicated

Types of Communication

Course Unit Lead should communicate:

  • Before sessions: Materials, guidance, any changes
  • During sessions: Available for immediate queries
  • After sessions: Feedback, follow-up on issues raised
  • Ongoing: Updates, reminders, information
  • Responsive: Replies to your emails and questions

Quality of Communication

  • Clear and specific – you understand what's expected
  • Professional tone – respectful and appropriate
  • Complete information – you have everything you need
  • Timely – in time for you to act on it
  • Accessible – language and format are understandable

If Communication Is Poor

  • Be explicit about what you need – "I need the session materials by Friday to prepare over the weekend."
  • Follow up on non-responses – after 48 hours, send a gentle reminder
  • Document communication issues – save emails, note when you sent/received messages
  • Raise with GTA Lead if it's affecting your work
  • Don't make assumptions – if something is unclear, ask for clarification

Flexibility and Understanding

What to Expect

  • Understanding if you need to drop the module due to work or personal reasons
  • Supportive response to reasonable requests (e.g., changing a session due to PhD commitment)
  • Recognition that you're a PhD student first – your research is priority
  • Reasonable expectations – not expecting you to work beyond contracted hours
  • Flexibility when possible – though this must be balanced with teaching needs

Examples of Reasonable Requests

  • "I have my PhD viva in week 8 – could another GTA cover my session that week?"
  • "I'm struggling with the workload this semester – could I reduce my hours next semester?"
  • "This is taking longer than the allocated time – could we discuss the expectations?"
  • "I'm unwell and can't make today's session – I've tried to arrange cover."

Course Unit Lead Should

  • Listen without judgement – hear your circumstances
  • Try to accommodate where possible – within constraints of teaching delivery
  • Be supportive – recognise you're managing multiple commitments
  • Help find solutions – not just say no
  • Respect confidentiality – you don't have to disclose personal details

What They Can't Always Do

  • Cancel sessions – teaching commitments must be met
  • Reduce session frequency – this is set by the module design
  • Guarantee flexibility – some things are non-negotiable
  • Solve PhD problems – they can be understanding but can't fix your research issues

The Key Principle

Course Unit Leads should be reasonable and treat you as a professional. They should recognise that:

  • Circumstances change
  • Life happens
  • You're doing your best to balance multiple roles
  • Communication and mutual respect matter

If You're Not Treated with Understanding

  • Clearly explain your situation – provide context for your request
  • Suggest solutions – show you're trying to be responsible
  • Involve your PhD supervisor – they can support your case if needed
  • Contact your GTA Lead – if the Course Unit Lead is unreasonable
  • Know your rights – you have employment protections

Teaching Materials and Preparation =

Complete and Quality Materials

What to Expect

  • Coursework prepared on Blackboard/Canvas and complete
  • Released to GTAs in time to study before the session
  • High quality – clear, accurate, appropriate for level
  • All necessary components – not missing pieces
  • Updated annually – not outdated or containing errors

"In Time" Means

  • Minimum 1 week before you need to use them
  • Earlier for complex material – programming assignments, long exercises
  • Earlier for marking – you need schemes before students submit
  • Ideally at start of semester – so you can see the whole unit

What "Complete" Means

  • All files present – no broken links or missing documents
  • Solutions provided (where relevant) – answers to exercises, code that works
  • Marking schemes (if you're marking) – clear criteria and grade boundaries
  • Supporting materials – any datasets, software, documentation needed

Quality Indicators

  • Accurate information – no errors or outdated content
  • Appropriate difficulty – matches the level of students
  • Clear instructions – students and GTAs understand what to do
  • Well-formatted – readable, accessible, professional
  • Tested – exercises work, code runs, links function

If Materials Are Inadequate

  • Flag specific issues – "The solution to question 3 doesn't compile" or "The marking scheme is missing section B"
  • Request corrections promptly – so they can be fixed before the session
  • Document what's missing – list specifically what you need
  • Offer to help if appropriate – "I could test the code if that would help"
  • Don't struggle on with bad materials – this affects teaching quality and your time

Software and Technical Resources

What to Expect

  • All necessary software available before sessions
  • Instructions for setup – how to access and use tools
  • Testing done – Course Unit Lead has checked everything works
  • Backup plans – what to do if systems fail
  • Technical support available – who to contact for IT issues

Your Preparation

  • Download necessary software before GTA sessions (as advised in CS GTA cheat sheet)
  • Test it works – don't wait until the session
  • Familiarise yourself with tools and interfaces
  • Report problems early – "I can't access the dataset" or "The software won't install"

Course Unit Lead Should

  • Provide clear instructions – how to get and use software
  • Test the full student journey – does the exercise actually work?
  • Anticipate common problems – and provide solutions
  • Be available for technical queries – especially first time you use something new

Technical Support

  • School IT support for installation and access issues
  • Course Unit Lead for subject-specific tool queries
  • Documentation and tutorials provided for complex tools

Model Answers and Worked Solutions

What to Expect

  • Complete worked solutions to exercises students will attempt
  • Model code that works – tested and debugged
  • Explanations of approaches – not just answers, but reasoning
  • Common variations – different valid ways to solve problems
  • Typical errors and how to fix them

Why This Matters

  • You can answer student questions confidently
  • You understand the expected approach – can guide students appropriately
  • You can debug effectively – compare student work to working model
  • Consistency – all GTAs teach the same correct approach
  • Saves your time – you don't have to work everything out yourself

For Programming Modules

  • Code should compile and run
  • Should be well-commented – explaining logic
  • Should demonstrate good practice – code students should emulate
  • Should match the exercise requirements – not over-engineered or too simple

If Solutions Aren't Provided

  • Request them explicitly – "Could I have the model solutions to prepare effectively?"
  • Explain why you need them – "Students will ask why their code doesn't work, and I need to compare to a correct version"
  • Allow time for Course Unit Lead to provide them – give reasonable notice
  • Collaborate with other GTAs – work together to understand the material
  • Escalate if necessary – if Course Unit Lead consistently doesn't provide solutions

Assessment and Marking

Marking Schemes and Criteria

What to Expect (If You're Marking)

  • Clear, detailed marking scheme provided before you start marking
  • Rubrics or criteria explaining what merits each grade
  • Model answers showing what constitutes different quality levels
  • Calibration opportunity – discussion or sample marking to ensure consistency
  • Guidance on common issues – what students typically struggle with

Timing

  • Before students submit – ideally when assignment is released
  • Minimum: before you start marking – you need it to mark fairly
  • Time to review and ask questions – you must understand the scheme

Quality of Marking Schemes

  • Specific – "Award 2 marks for defining the term correctly" not "Award marks for understanding"
  • Comprehensive – covers all parts of the assignment
  • Aligned with assessment – marks allocated match the questions
  • Fair – objective criteria that can be applied consistently
  • Explained – you understand the reasoning behind the grades

Support in Marking

  • Opportunity to discuss the scheme – ask questions and clarify
  • Calibration exercise – mark sample work and compare with Course Unit Lead
  • Ongoing support – can ask about borderline cases
  • Moderation – Course Unit Lead checks a sample of your marking
  • Feedback on your marking – how to improve for next time

If Marking Scheme Is Inadequate

  • Ask for clarification – "How should I mark question 3?"
  • Request examples – "Could you show me what a 2:1 answer looks like?"
  • Raise specific issues – "The scheme doesn't cover students who used approach X"
  • Don't guess – if unsure, ask rather than make up criteria
  • Document ambiguities – note where scheme was unclear

Moderation and Quality Assurance

What to Expect

  • Your marking will be checked – this is policy and normal practice
  • Feedback on your marking – what you did well, what to adjust
  • Marks may be adjusted – to ensure consistency and standards
  • Supportive approach – helping you develop marking skills, not criticism
  • Process explained – you understand how moderation works

Why Moderation Happens

  • University policy – GTAs cannot have sole responsibility for marking
  • Quality assurance – ensures standards are maintained
  • Fairness to students – consistent marking across all scripts
  • Your development – learning to mark well is a skill
  • Not personal – it's about the process, not questioning your ability

How to Respond to Moderation

  • Accept feedback positively – it's developmental, not critical
  • Ask questions – "Why was this mark adjusted?"
  • Learn from it – apply feedback to future marking
  • Don't take adjustments personally – even experienced markers have variation
  • Use it to improve – marking is a skill you're developing

Problem Resolution and Support

When Issues Arise

Course Unit Lead Should

  • Listen to your concerns without dismissing them
  • Take problems seriously – not minimise or ignore
  • Work with you to find solutions – collaborative approach
  • Act on issues – make changes where needed
  • Follow up – check the problem is resolved

Types of Problems Course Unit Lead Should Address

  • Inadequate materials or preparation
  • Student behaviour issues
  • Unclear expectations or changing requirements
  • Workload exceeding contracted hours
  • Technical problems affecting teaching
  • Safety concerns
  • Issues with other GTAs

Problem-Solving Process

  1. You raise the issue – clearly and specifically
  2. Course Unit Lead listens – takes it seriously
  3. Discussion – understanding the problem fully
  4. Solutions proposed – Course Unit Lead or together
  5. Action taken – changes implemented
  6. Follow-up – check it's resolved

If Course Unit Lead Doesn't Address Issues

  • Be more explicit – perhaps they didn't understand the seriousness
  • Put it in writing – email creates a record
  • Escalate to your GTA Lead – Simon Harper for CS GTAs
  • Document everything – keep records of issues and your attempts to resolve them
  • Know your rights – some issues are serious enough for formal processes

Feedback on Your Teaching

What to Expect

  • Regular, informal feedback – "That explanation worked well" or "Students seemed confused about X"
  • Constructive approach – focusing on development, not criticism
  • Specific examples – not vague comments
  • Balanced – acknowledging strengths as well as areas to develop
  • Actionable – suggestions for improvement, not just critique

When Feedback Should Be Given

  • Immediately after sessions – brief comments on what went well/could improve
  • Mid-semester – more formal review of your teaching
  • End of semester – overall assessment and development for future
  • Ongoing – responsive to your requests for feedback

How Feedback Should Be Delivered

  • Private – not in front of students or other GTAs
  • Respectful tone – supportive, not harsh
  • Two-way conversation – you can respond and discuss
  • Focuses on behaviour, not personality – "Try explaining that concept differently" not "You're not a clear explainer"
  • Offers support – "Would you like to observe how I tackle that topic?"

Asking for Feedback

  • You can request feedback – "How do you think that session went?"
  • Be specific – "I struggled with explaining X – do you have suggestions?"
  • Shows professionalism – wanting to improve demonstrates good practice
  • Course Unit Lead should welcome this – and provide thoughtful feedback

If You Receive Unfair or Unhelpful Feedback

  • Ask for clarification – "Could you explain what you mean?"
  • Request specific examples – "When did you observe that?"
  • Discuss your perspective – there may be context they don't know
  • If feedback is unprofessional – harsh, personal, or humiliating – this is unacceptable
  • Report unprofessional feedback to your GTA Lead

Professional Standards and Respect

Mutual Respect

What Respect Looks Like

  • Polite communication – courteous tone in person and writing
  • Timely responses – valuing your time by replying promptly
  • Listening – genuinely hearing your questions and concerns
  • Acknowledging your contributions – thanking you for your work
  • Treating you as a colleague – not as a subordinate or servant
  • Recognising your expertise – valuing what you bring
  • Professional boundaries – appropriate relationship, not overly familiar or cold

What Disrespect Looks Like

  • Dismissive communication – "Just deal with it" or ignoring concerns
  • Unavailability – consistently not responding or inaccessible
  • Undermining you – contradicting you in front of students
  • Blame – making you responsible for their failings
  • Inappropriate behaviour – anything making you uncomfortable
  • Discrimination – treating you differently based on protected characteristics
  • Exploitation – expecting work beyond contracted hours without payment

Your Right to Respectful Treatment

Professional Conduct

Course Unit Lead Should Model

  • Punctuality – arriving on time for sessions
  • Preparation – materials ready, organised
  • Professionalism – appropriate behaviour and communication
  • Ethical conduct – honesty, integrity, fairness
  • Commitment – fulfilling their responsibilities
  • Respect for students – appropriate boundaries and support

Why This Matters

  • Sets the standard for the teaching team
  • You learn professional behaviour by observation
  • Creates positive environment – professionalism makes work better
  • Students see good modelling – affects their behaviour too
  • Makes your job easier – working with professional staff is smoother

When Expectations Aren't Met

Addressing Issues Directly

First Step: Communication

Before escalating, try to address issues directly with the Course Unit Lead (unless the issue is serious misconduct or makes you unsafe).

How to raise concerns:

  • Choose the right time – not in the middle of a session, but soon after
  • Be specific – "I didn't receive the materials for next week's session" not "You're not supporting me"
  • Focus on impact – "Without the solutions, I can't help students debug their code"
  • Suggest solutions – "Could materials be posted on Fridays for the following week?"
  • Stay professional – calm, factual tone even if you're frustrated

Why direct communication first:

  • May be unintentional – they might not realise there's a problem
  • Quick resolution – can often be fixed immediately
  • Maintains relationship – shows you're professional and collaborative
  • Escalation may not be needed – saves everyone time and stress

When Direct Communication Isn't Appropriate

Don't attempt to address directly if:

  • The issue involves bullying or harassment
  • You feel unsafe or intimidated
  • It's a serious breach of policy or ethics
  • You've tried before and nothing changed
  • The Course Unit Lead is actively hostile to feedback

Summary: What Good Looks Like

A Good Course Unit Lead

Communication

  • Introduces themselves before teaching starts
  • Responds to emails within 48 hours
  • Provides clear, complete information
  • Welcomes questions and discussion
  • Keeps you informed of changes

Materials and Preparation

  • Provides materials at least 1 week ahead
  • Materials are complete, tested, and high quality
  • Gives weekly guidance relevant to upcoming sessions
  • Ensures you have everything needed to teach effectively

Support and Availability

  • Attends all scheduled sessions (or arranges cover)
  • Is approachable and helpful
  • Steps in when problems arise
  • Provides constructive feedback
  • Supports your development as a teacher

Professionalism

  • Models good professional behaviour
  • Treats you with respect
  • Is organised and prepared
  • Fulfils their responsibilities
  • Maintains appropriate boundaries

Flexibility and Understanding

  • Recognises you're a PhD student first
  • Is understanding about work-life balance
  • Is reasonable with requests when possible
  • Doesn't expect unpaid work beyond your contract
  • Supports you when circumstances change

Your Experience Should Be

  • Supported – you have what you need to do your job well
  • Valued – your contributions are recognised and appreciated
  • Professional – you're treated with respect as a colleague
  • Developmental – you're learning and improving as a teacher
  • Sustainable – the work is manageable alongside your PhD
  • Positive – overall, the experience is rewarding, not stressful

← Back to GTA Main Page